The brush itself looks almost exactly like the Maybelline The Falsies Black Drama Waterproof, just without the bendy and flimsy part of the wand. Also, the spoon itself looks very different in person than it does on the website. From what I know, the brand's swatches and photos seem to be quite different than what the actual product is in real life.
I don't like it when brands try to deceive the customers, let's just get that clear.
I've used the mascara about three times now and I don't get a lot of volume with this mascara, but then again, I don't get a ton of volume with any mascara claiming to be dramatic and voluminous. Instead, I get either natural looking lashes or a clumping party with a handful of lashes being stuck together.
For me, this works better as a mascara for the bottom lashes. I still get many of the clumps on my bottom lashes, but since the applicator is smaller than those on my other mascaras, and it's not as bendy and filmsy, I can get a steady hold on it and put on the mascara without getting a bunch of smudges on my lower lash line.
Even though it's a waterproof mascara, it isn't a total pain to take off, which I think is great. I've been using Benefit They're Real! mascara as well and that's a non-waterproof mascara and is much harder for me to take off. Lash Gallery will require a little bit of makeup remover, but it shouldn't be a huge fuss.
For $20, I don't think this is a must have mascara by any means and considering Michelle's fanbase consists of girls mostly under the age of eighteen, I'm quite shocked that her prices are so high since middle and high school students don't have a lot of money to spend on makeup unless it's being provided by their parents.
Overall, this is a decent mascara depending on your needs and it isn't terrible, but I don't think it's priced correctly. This isn't anything an $8 mascara from the drugstore can't do.
RELATED QUESTION: Have you tried the makeup from Michelle Phan's new makeup brand?